Emergency Fund – Do you Really Need One in 2019?

Posted on

(Disclosure: Some of the links below may be affiliate links. For more information, read my disclosure.)

Do you really need an Emergency Fund _

If you are interested in personal finance, you probably have come across the term Emergency Fund. An Emergency Fund is simply some money, available directly, that you can use in case of emergency. Most people will advise you to get such an account. And they will insist heavily on this subject.

It is an interesting subject since not everybody agrees on it. Some people have an emergency fund that can cover one year of expenses. And some people think you do not need one.

Personally, I do not think an emergency fund is a bad thing. But you should be aware of its cost. It also has disadvantages. And you may not need a fund as big as some people tell you. I think that too much people put too much emphasis on the emergency fund.

In this post, we are going to see both sides of the story. We are going to see in details what an emergency fund is.

Emergency Funds

An emergency fund is nothing special. It is just a simple bank account where you store away some money that you may need for emergencies. A general rule of thumb is to store three to six months of your expenses. But some people will save away more than one year of expense.

It is important to base that on your expenses and not on your income. You are not spending your income! Or at least, you should not!

Where should you save this money?

There is something really important about emergency funds. If you believe that you need to have one, you should have one in a very liquid account.

It does not make sense to invest your emergency in highly liquid stocks. If you need the money today, you may have to sell at a very bad price. It should be in a savings bank account.

Ideally, you want to save the money in a high-interest bank account. However, sometimes this is not possible. For instance, some bank accounts have limitations as to when you can withdraw the money. You really want this money to be available instantly.

And in some countries, bank accounts have no interest rates, like in Switzerland these last years. In this case, you can simply keep it in your salary bank account. This makes it very easy.

If you feel like you need a separate bank account, feel free to separate it completely. Just make sure you are not paying any fees to store your emergency money!

Some people save their emergency fund in a money-market account. If you have a good account like this available, it may be a good option. They generally have higher yields. But you need to make sure that you can withdraw the money easily and for free.

Reasons for having an emergency fund

Why you should have an emergency fund? In case of emergency, you have something to pay for it.

  • Imagine you have a very large medical bill coming (2500 CHF), can you pay it?
  • Or if your car breaks down and you have to replace it.
  • Your house is flooded and you have to pay a large bill
  • Your phone breaks and you have to replace it

There are many more reasons that make people want to have an emergency fund.

In general, I believe that being able to cover any emergency is a great thing. But these funds have a large cost. And most people do not consider this cost when they advise an emergency fund.

The cost of an emergency fund

There are several disadvantages to having an emergency fund. You will need to balance these disadvantages to know how big of a fund you need.

The opportunity cost

Emergency Funds have one big problem: The opportunity cost. The simple fact of not investing this money is costing you. Opportunity costs are something that many people never consider. But it is a very important concept.

Instead of having this money in a savings account, you could invest it in an ETF that would give you an average 5% per year (I am being conservative). So you are losing out on these returns.

Let’s take my current emergency fund of 15000 CHF as an example. Investing it could yield me 750 CHF per year. This is a lot! And this is not taking into account compounding interest over the years. You need to be aware of this. If you have access to high yielding interest account, it may be acceptable. But we do not have anything like this in Switzerland.

If your savings account yields you less than inflation, you are actually losing money every year. In most countries, saving accounts have lower interest rates than inflation. This is almost always the case.

If you really want an emergency fund, there is nothing you can do about this cost. But maybe you do not need one. Or maybe you need a smaller one than you think?

The distraction factor

One thing that many people do not realize is that having a large emergency fund will distract you from your other financial goals.

If you set yourself to save one year of expenses for emergencies, you will need quite some time to do it. For most people, this will probably take a few years. This means that during this time, you will have no time working on your other goals.

Having a smaller fund would let you work on your other goals as well. This could let you reduce your debts. Or you could save money towards a down payment on a house.

The temptation factor

There is another cost related to emergency fund: The Temptation. You may be tempted to use that money lying in your emergency account. This should not happen to frugal and responsible people. But this is something that may happen. You may think that it is a good place to take money for that brand new TV you wanted!

If you start taking money out of this fund without an emergency, it really becomes useless. You may well not have money on it

Do you really need an emergency fund?

I may get some dislikes from this section. But I think it is important to know about it!

You may not need an emergency fund as much as you think. Or at least, you may not need it to be as big as you think. There are a lot of people living very well without one.

Of course, not having an emergency will not prevent you from having to pay for an emergency if it happens. So, how to pay if there is an emergency?

  • With your credit card
  • Use your next paycheck to pay it
  • Sell some equities

If you have a large limit on your credit card, you can actually pay a lot of emergency bills with it. Or withdraw money to pay for them. If you are saving a large percentage of your income, you have a lot of margin to pay for emergencies each month. That just means you will invest less the following month.

And a lot of risks are not as great as you think:

  • If you have health insurance, you only have to pay the deductible. This is only 2500 CHF for me.
  • If you have car insurance, you only have to pay the deductible as well. This is 1000 CHF for me at maximum.
  • If you get fired or do not find a new job after the current one, you should receive unemployment benefits for several months. And unless you did something really wrong, if you get fired, you will get a severance package.
  • If I die, I have got life insurance with which my wife can live for several years.
  • Lots of things can be planned. For instance, it is not very difficult to estimate when you need new tires. This is something you can budget for. You should try to plan for big expenses. For a lot of people, emergencies could be avoided with better budgeting.

As you can see, you are already protected for very large unexpected expenses. If you have a stable income, a good credit card and you save a large part of your income, you can have a small emergency fund only. Or even no emergency fund at all.

Of course, if you have no insurance for anything, this may not be the same issue. You need to study the risk you are not protected against.

Saying that everybody needs three to six months of expenses in cash is just dumb.

This will of course highly depends on your situation. Some people have more risks than others to lose their jobs. And this can also depend from one country to another. This is why you need to assess your own situation.

Moreover, if you know that you are not good at managing money and keeping on budget, you should probably not avoid emergency funds. But once again, this will depend on each situation.

Emergency funds in retirement

In retirement, things will be very different.

If you are following the 4% withdrawal rule (or any other withdrawal rate) from The Trinty Study, you will live from your withdrawals. You have two choices for this: monthly withdrawals or yearly withdrawals.

Generally, monthly withdrawals are a bit better in the long-term. But yearly withdrawals are easier to manage.

If you opt for monthly withdrawals, you will only have one month of expenses in cash ready to be used. In that case, you may want to use a second account for your emergencies.

With yearly withdrawals, you do not really need an emergency fund. You already have one year of expenses in a cash account. If there is an emergency, this will simply mean that you will have to sell shares earlier than intended.

My emergency fund

Let’s now talk about The Poor Swiss emergency fund.

Once I did this research originally, I had an emergency fund of 15’000 CHF. At that time, this was more than three months of expenses. But I realized that this was too much. Given my safe situation, I decided to lower it.

Now, I keep an account of 10’000 CHF. This is a bit less than two months of expenses. I feel this is more than enough for us.  I am simply keeping it in my main bank account. It is simpler like this. And bank accounts in Switzerland do not currently yield any interest.

We are able to save up to 50% of our income each month. That means one salary is covering the expenses of two months. We can also cover about one month expenses with our credit card as well. I have health insurance with a deductible with 2500 CHF deductible. And I have full insurance for my car with a deductible of 1000 CHF. That highly reduces the risk.

Moreover, I have more than 15’000 CHF available if I use my credit cards. This could be used to pay for some big expenses. And this could be paid quickly the following months.

So, I decided to only keep 10’000 CHF for emergencies. I am really comfortable with that amount for both Mrs. The Poor Swiss and me.

Advocates of small emergency funds

Of course, you should not only take my word for it.

There are many people in the personal finance community that are advocates of small emergency funds. There are even some people that think that they are not useful.

For instance, Big ERN at earlyretirement.now has an emergency fund of 0$ and gives you 10 reasons why they are not good. I really recommend this article.

Go Curry Cracker also mentioned that Emergency Funds are overrated. If you have a strong financial status, you may not need an emergency fund as strongly as you think.

Another advocate of a smaller emergency fund is Mr. Money Mustache (Pete Adeney). You can watch this video by Pete to learn more about his point of view:

Conclusion

Emergency funds are a good tool to protect you against big emergency expenses. However, they have a big cost because that money is sleeping without bringing any interest. Generally, bank accounts interest is lower than inflation. So your emergency money is losing value every year. Moreover, you are generally more protected against big expenses.

In my opinion, an emergency fund is a good thing. But you should not have a too big emergency fund. If you have an income, I do not see the point in having eight months of expenses saved up. If you are able to save a large part of your salary, you are already covered for some big expenses. And of course, you need savings! Nobody advises you to have zero savings. But you should invest most of your savings.

I think that everybody should have a small emergency fund of at least one month of expenses. But having more may not be as necessary as other people would tell you. And having a huge reserve is actually doing more harm than good to your finances.

If your financial situation is bad, the first thing you need to do it to get out of debt. Then, you need to increase your savings rate as much as possible. The emergency fund will only come after this. And once you start saving more money, it will come naturally.

To learn about another kind of fund, you can read my article about the opportunity fund.

Do you have an emergency fund? How many months of expenses do you keep into it?

Mr. The Poor Swiss

Mr. The Poor Swiss is the author behind thepoorswiss.com. In 2017, he realized that he was falling into the trap of lifestyle inflation. He decided to cut on his expenses and increase his income. This blog is relating his story and findings. In 2019, he is saving more than 50% of his income. He made it a goal to reach Financial Independence. You can send Mr. The Poor Swiss a message here.

14 thoughts on “Emergency Fund – Do you Really Need One in 2019?”

  1. If you have a family with kids, you might need to increase your emergency fund. We wrote once a blogpost about the size of an emergency fund dependent on your family situation. With your savings rate, there is no need for a big fund, I agree. With 3 teenagers kids our emergency fund is more than 1 year now to cover our expenses.

    1. I completely agree! It’s highly depending on each person’s situation. It needs to be reconsidered based on the possible emergencies. If you have several teenager kids, you should have more of an emergency fund. And it also depends on the income and on the savings rate. I would still think that 12 months is a bit too much though, no ?

      Thanks for stopping by

    2. “1 year now to cover our expenses.” The purpose of an emergnecy fund is NOT to cover your expected expenses, but unexpected ones.

      1. Hi Zoltan

        I also agree that you should not want to cover your expenses with it. However, your running expenses are more easy to compute than your unexpected expenses. Moreover, loss of job will have a cost directly related to your running expenses.

        Thanks for stopping by

  2. So wise.
    I recently had cataract surgery and my insurance didn’t cover the Type of procedure I needed.
    It wasn’t technically an Emergency but my vision had suddenly started getting worse.
    So, small price to pay in that sense.
    One of my worst fears has always been losing my sight.
    So, the grand total out of pocket was about three thousand.
    On top of the almost TEN thousand we pay in premiums every year.
    I try not to think about it too much, it’ll make you crazy lol
    Victoria

    1. Hi Victoria,

      It is an excellent example, thanks for sharing!

      It may not be directly an emergency fund but unless you save a lot of money each month, this will need to be covered by your emergency fund. I think it’s a good example.
      And it’s really sad that it’s not covered by insurance. Losing sight should definitely be covered…

      As you said, it’s crazy. We paid thousands each year in premium and then we still have to pay thousands in deductible and some things are still not covered.
      All that because a lot of people are using their insurance for small things.
      I try not to think either too much about it.

      Thanks a lot for stopping by!

  3. Thanks for sharing your view and gave concrete numbers regarding the size of your emergency fund. I think 10k for 2 people who are frugal and can manage their cash flow well is more than sufficient. Plus Switzerland is a country with lots of protection like the unemployment and severance benefits that you’ve mentioned.

    I do want to add that having 3-6 months of emergency fund is generally not a bad idea for Americans who generally:

    – have a low saving rate (5% average)
    – can’t handle their money well (I.e. love to spend $$$ due to the prevalent consumerism culture)
    – have kids and depending on how many
    – have health issues

    The last one could be the biggest unexpected expenses.

    1. Hi Mama Bear,

      Yes, I think we are pretty safe with our situation :)

      However, I completely agree with you that if you are in a bad financial situation, having a larger one could be very good.
      The problem is that some people hide behind their emergency funds and do nothing else with their finances. It’s a great first step. But it’s not enough to really have a good situation (out of debt, good savings rate, …).
      But it’s also a good point that people with bad health and bad insurance coverage should have higher emergency funds.

      Thanks a lot for stopping by!

  4. We have never had an emergency fund but we always had access to more credit than we used. We kept a home equity line as our emergency fund, and since you pay interest on everything you used, there was a built-in check and balance to the temptation of just using it. At the same time, it was more money than we would want to keep in a zero-interest account so it served well as an emergency stash.

    1. Hi Caroline,

      Yes, a large credit can help a lot in case of an emergency. A line of credit on the house can be an option to have a large emergency fund.

      Did you have to use your emergency line of credit?

      Thanks for stopping by!

  5. Maybe a bit off topic but how do you save for a downpayment if you know you want to make use of it in the next 2-5 years?
    Can’t really invest in stock cuz who knows where they are at by then… would you just keep it on your bank account or invest it somehow?

    Thanks a lot
    Great article as always – makes me realize that I don’t need too much in my emergency fund.

    1. Hi Peter Pan,

      Actually, I think it depends if it’s two or five years.
      If it’s in the next 2 years, I would keep it in cash. I would maybe invest some in P2P Lending, but definitely not a lot.
      If it’s in the next 5 years, I would still invest in the stock market. In between 2 and 5 years, I do not really know honestly.

      Thanks for stopping by!

  6. Hy
    Good Topic. Good review. I think the emergency fund is very idiosyncratic. Someone who lives alone in rent and has a saving rate of 50% may not Need a big emergency fund. A Family who lives in an own house (you have to do renovations and buy household articles) and has a very low saving rate may Need a bigger emergency fund. Maybe there is also differences between countries. In Switzerland you have a good social System. I dont know other countries but I can imagine that not in all countries exist good healthcare, unemployment and other insurances.

    What an Advantage of building an emergency fund is that it should motivate People with bad spending behaviours. For them it is often the first step how to learn spend less and save more. So for them it could be a good Goal to save an amount of 3 month spendings. Then when they become more Aware maybe they can reduce the amount of the fund.

    I was also a messy spender and built up an emergency fund of 3 month spending. But I never needed it because when something happened I saved less. So after 2 years I decided to reduce this amount to 1 month, and after another year I dont have an emergency fund.
    I agree, in Switzerland you are good insured in case of bad luck and in case you are not a messy spender there is no Need for a bigger emergency fund than 1-3 month expenses.
    Maybe other People with less spending awarenes in other countries could Need a bigger emergency fund.

    1. Hi KM,

      That’s a good point! Your need for an emergency fund will also be related to your savings rate. If you are able to save 5000 CHF per month, you have 5000 CHF ready for an emergency in 30 days.

      And as you said, and as mentioned in the article, it will highly depend on what you are covered for in your country.

      It was already mentioned in the comments that people with bad spending habits will need a larger emergency fund that people that carefully watch their expenses. Once they get their expenses in order, they can start reducing it, as you dit!

      Congratulations on having no emergency fund!

      Thanks for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *