(Disclosure: Some of the links below may be affiliate links)
In Switzerland, there are many differences between the different states (or cantons). Can you take advantage of these differences and do geo arbitrage inside Switzerland? We are talking about arbitrage for money advantages.
Most people using geo arbitrage are doing it in different countries. For instance, several people work in Switzerland but then plan to retire in a cheaper country. But I think there are opportunities within Switzerland.
So, we explore the different opportunities for geo arbitrage within Switzerland. Let’s see if people can get more money or reduce their taxes by moving within Switzerland.
What is geo arbitrage?
Geo arbitrage is a technique where you optimize where you work and where you will be retiring. The idea is to get the most of each place. In this article, we focus on the financial implications of specific locations.
But you could use geo arbitrage to find for the best schools for your children. Or you could choose a state based on the best medical care. Some people are simply choosing a place to live based on the sights.
But, let’s focus on the money part. For instance, you could work in the city with the highest salary and then retire in the city with the cheapest capital taxes.
Or you can even optimize it further by working in a city and living in another city with lower taxes. And then once you are Financially Independent, you could move to another city or country.
Geo arbitrage can happen at many levels, even districts of a city. If you take a large city like Geneva, where you live inside it will matter. However, most people are considering it for countries. But there is no limit to which you can apply it.
If your goal is to achieve Financial Independence as fast as possible, then geo arbitrage is a very powerful technique.
There are some disadvantages to geo arbitrage. The biggest is that you will have to move at some points. It means you will have to leave your friends and families. It also means you have to organize many things in advance. Doing that may be overwhelming. And in some cases, people end up not moving after a while because they have grown attached to the place they lived for a few years.
I would not move to another state. I like the place where we live. And all my friends and family are still in the same state. I have strong ties to this region. But I completely understand that some people have weaker ties. For those people, it makes a lot of sense to move around to optimize. It is even truer for people that pursue Financial Independence.
Increase your income
The main reason in Switzerland for people to move to another state is to get a higher salary. There are some substantial differences in income between states and cities.
For instance, the state of Zurich is the state with the highest income average in Switzerland. And the state of Ticino is the state with the lowest income in Switzerland.
I found this great visual representation from the Federal Statistics Office (Source).
There is more than a 1000 CHF monthly difference between the highest paying and the lowest paying states.
There are also some significant differences inside the states. For instance, you may not be paid the same in small villages in Geneva than in Geneva city.
Consequently, the two cities with the highest income (Zurich and Geneva) are also the most expensive in Switzerland.
You could take advantage of this by moving to a high-income city when you work. And then you could move to a cheaper city when you retire. It can make a very significant difference.
Reduce your taxes
Optimizing taxes is an excellent reason to use geo arbitrage. In Switzerland, the taxes can be very different from one state to another. If you are a high-income earner, you may want to move to another state.
We can take a look at the taxation for an income of 100’000 CHF in different states. I found a list of taxes from 2014 on Wikipedia (Source).
For a single person, there is a factor three of difference between the lowest tax state, Zug, and the highest tax state, Neuchatel. It is interesting that for a married couple, there is almost a factor 8 difference! And it also interesting to note that the cheapest and highest are the same for a single person than for married couples with children.
We can also look at what happens with an income of 200’000 CHF.
The same stats are the cheapest and the most expensive. But there is less difference between the top and the bottom. A single person pays 2.3 times fewer taxes in Zug than in Neuchatel. And a married couple with two children would pay 4.6 times cheaper.
Whether you have children or not, moving to another state for taxes, reason can be an excellent geo arbitrage opportunity! If you can save 20’000 CHF per year on taxes, you can probably retire a few years earlier.
If you have a large net worth, you will pay some wealth tax. This can become significant as your wealth increases.
Again, there are some huge discrepancies between different states. Zug is still very cheap, but it is not the cheapest state for wealth taxes. Generally, the best states for the wealth taxes are Nidwald and Obwald. And the worst is generally Neuchatel.
These differences can be a lot. For instance, for a wealth of one million CHF, you will pay about 0.015% in Nidwald and 0.07% in Neuchatel. This is almost five times more expensive!
This is very important when your plan is to become financially independent. At this point, you should have a large wealth and a low income. In this stage of your life, it could be very beneficial to move to another state. It could make a large difference in your yearly expenses.
You can also consider moving to another county to save taxes. We also pay county taxes. These are generally a percentage of the state taxes. And they can vary quite a lot. In the state of Fribourg, it varies from 32% in Greng to 100% in Jaun. There is a factor three difference in your county taxes.
Generally, it is simpler to move from one county to the other than it is moving to another state. It can make a significant difference to your financial situation if you want to optimize your finances.
Reduce your spending
We also have some significant differences in prices between cities. Some things have almost no differences, like appliances or groceries. But some things like services and rent can differ wildly. Some things are actually cheap in Switzerland.
I did not find sufficient data to compare each city in Switzerland or even each state. However, Zurich is known to be one of the most expensive cities in the world, and so is Geneva. On the other hand, a small town in Ticino would probably be around 30% to 40% cheaper.
One good indicator is the price of rent in each state.
We can see that there are some major differences between states. Between Jura and Zug, there is a factor two for the average rent price. It is interesting to note that the state with the most expensive rent is also the state with the cheapest taxes.
Considering the prices of the state and cities is something good when you consider retiring in Switzerland. Now, it is not worth the trouble for a few percents. But it could be worth the trouble for 20% reduced expenses, for instance. Moving for retirement could mean you need to accumulate 20% less money to become Financially Independent.
Buy a cheaper house
If your goal is to buy a house or an apartment in Switzerland, it will make a huge difference where you are planning to buy. There are immense discrepancies between states and cities.
I am no expert at real estate, but I know that house prices are quite crazy these days. I found some statistics about house prices. We can take a look at the price per square meter for houses and apartments.
As you can see, there are considerable disparities in prices. The cheaper state for houses (Jura) is 2.8 times less expensive than the most expensive state (Geneva). For houses, the difference is 4.2 times more expensive.
If your goal is to buy a nice house, it could make sense to choose a state based on the price of the real estate properties.
Pay less for health insurance
Another big difference between states in Switzerland is the price of health insurance.
Indeed, each insurance has a different plan for each state. This is based on the demographics of each region and the prices of each region.
For instance, here are the three states with the most expensive average health insurance premiums:
- Basel-Town: 567 CHF
- Geneva: 554 CHF
- Vaud: 495 CHF
And here are the three states with the cheapest average health insurance premiums:
- Appenzell Inner Rhodes: 348 CHF
- Nidwald: 361 CHF
- Ury: 369 CHF
As we can observe, there are some very significant differences between the states. I do not think this is enough to make anybody move. But it could be interesting to consider this when you are moving around in Switzerland.
As you can see, there are tons of opportunities for geo arbitrage in Switzerland. There are so many differences between states, counties, and even cities. It makes the financial situation between locations very different.
If you want to optimize your finances, there are many opportunities. Whether you can move will depend on your ability to move and on your job. But with some jobs, you could double your income. By moving to another town, you could divide your taxes by two. Or, if you want a house, you could get one four times cheaper by moving to a more affordable place.
Now, I am not recommending you to move around to optimize everything. I am not planning to move just for the sake of saving money. Geo arbitrage is not for everybody. But it is a very powerful tool. If you have strong goals and are very motivated, you can take advantage of geo arbitrage to reach your goals much faster.
If you want more details about Switzerland, I have collected a large set of statistics about Switzerland.
What do you think? Did you every consider geo arbitrage inside Switzerland?